Skip to main content

P3 hospitals go poof -- Should P3 lenders take a haircut too?

The mother country of public private partnerships (P3s) is now preparing to take over a nearly bankrupt health care trust that runs three hospitals.  Like other British hospitals, the South London hospital trust was devastated by its P3 deals.

The mother country in question -- Britain --  will take over the hospitals and run them under a trusteeship, probably within weeks.

A Department of Health official reports the hospital trust is spending £61 million per year on two P3 deals, forking over 14% of its income.  The hospital trust is losing £1 million a week.   The trust has accumulated a deficit of £150m (about $240 million). 

The P3 fiasco has led some Conservatives to question whether the P3 deals transfer risk to the private sector.

With the announcement, a senior Conservative British MP, Stephen Dorrell (the former health secretary who now chairs the Commons health select committee), suggests that P3 lenders should, like lenders to Greece, bear their share of risk and take "a haircut" when things go wrong. 

The Conservative MP adds that private finance initiative "as originally conceived 20 years ago was to achieve some risk transfer, to engage the private sector in making this kind of judgment and to carry some of the risk."  

Dorrell  regrets that "agreements were signed which effectively paid private sector cost when the public sector took the risk. That is indefensible." 

The alleged risk transfer to the private sector is the main way the P3 industry justifies the extra costs associated with P3s.

Mike Farrar, the chief executive of the NHS Confederation noted  "To recover the kind of sums you are facing in south London you really do need wholesale redesign of services in order to get something sustainable for the future".

Earlier this year the government announced that 22 trusts were suffering financial problems due to their P3 deals, providing some with extra funding to prevent disaster.  

The Department of Health has set goals for twenty trusts overseeing 60 hospitals  -- but they may ultimately face special measures similar to the South London hospital trust.

The Telegraph reports there are fears that services such as accident and emergency departments will be cut or downgraded to save money, or that some hospitals could close.  Sources close to the health secretary report that the South London's hospital trust’s deficit last year was equal to the salaries of 1,200 nurses or 200 hip replacements a week.

The British P3 model has been exported to other countries, including Canada and Ontario.


Popular posts from this blog

Public sector employment in Ontario is far below the rest of Canada

The suggestion that Ontario has a deficit because its public sector is too large does not bear scrutiny. Consider the following. 

Public sector employment has fallen in the last three quarters in Ontario.  Since 2011, public sector employment has been pretty flat, with employment up less than 4 tenths of one percent in the first half of 2015 compared with the first half of 2011.

This contrasts with public sector employment outside of Ontario which has gone up pretty consistently and is now 4.7% higher than it was in the first half of 2011.

Private sector employment has also gone up consistently over that period. In Ontario, it has increased 4.3% since the first half of 2011, while in Canada as a whole it has increased 4.9%.

As a result, public sector employment in Ontario is now shrinking as a percentage of the private sector workforce.  In contrast, in the rest of Canada, it is increasing. Moreover, public sector employment is muchhigher in the rest of Canada than in Ontario.  Indeed as…

The long series of failures of private clinics in Ontario

For many years, OCHU/CUPE has been concerned the Ontario government would transfer public hospital surgeries, procedures and diagnostic tests to private clinics. CUPE began campaigning in earnest against this possibility in the spring of 2007 with a tour of the province by former British Health Secretary, Frank Dobson, who talked about the disastrous British experience with private surgical clinics.

The door opened years ago with the introduction of fee-for-service hospital funding (sometimes called Quality Based Funding). Then in the fall of 2013 the government announced regulatory changes to facilitate this privatization. The government announced Request for Proposals for the summer of 2014 to expand the role of "Independent Health Facilities" (IHFs). 

With mass campaigns to stop the private clinic expansion by the Ontario Health Coalition the process slowed.  

But it seems the provincial Liberal government continues to push the idea.  Following a recent second OCHU tour wi…

Hospital worker sick leave: too much or too little?

Ontario hospital workers are muchless absent due to illness or disability than hospital workers Canada-wide.  In 2014, Ontario hospital workers were absent 10.2 days due to illness or disability, 2.9 days less than the Canada wide average – i.e. 22% less.  In fact, Ontario hospital workers have had consistently fewer sick days for years.

This is also true if absences due to family or personal responsibilities are included.
Statistics Canada data for the last fifteen years for Canada and Ontario are reported in the chart below, showing Ontario hospital workers are consistently off work less.
Assuming, Ontario accounts for about 38% of the Canada-wide hospital workforce, these figures suggest that the days lost due to illness of injury in Canada excluding Ontario are about 13.6 days per year ([13.6 x 0.68] + [10.2 x 0.38] = 13.1).

In other words, hospital workers in the rest of Canada are absent from work due to illness or disability 1/3 more than Ontario hospital workers. 

In fact, Canad…