US and Canadian public health care costs compared

USA government health care costs far exceed Canadian costs

Despite the lack of universal public insurance, U.S. governments actually spend much more on health care than Canadian governments.

Public sector health expenditure in the U.S.A. accounts for 8.5% of the economy, 7.9% in Canada, and 6.8% through the OECD (the club of 34 rich nations – which, unlike the U.S.A., primarily finance health care through the public sector).

Indeed, the U.S. public sector spends more per capita on health care than any other OECD nation except Norway – $4066 per capita (in 2011). The universal Canadian system spends $3183, while the OECD average is $2,499.

The main feature of the US system that distinguishes it from the systems in other developed countries is that it is highly privatized.

Moreover, it's not that the U.S. hasn't quite got privatization right: basic problems remain despite multiple reforms to private health care.

As the U.S.A. is the leading model of private health care provision, why would any jurisdiction consider moving towards more private health care?

Ontario U.S.A.: Despite the negative results of the privatized U.S. health care model, Ontario is trying to expand private health care delivery through private surgical and diagnostic clinics.

Past experience shows that private clinics are much more aggressive at collecting private payments from patients for services than public hospitals.

So it is notable that Ontario already has the highest share of private payment for health care in the country, according to data in a recent report from the Canadian Institute for Health Information (CIHI). Private expenditures in Ontario run to 32.3% of total health expenditures, higher than any other province (Saskatchewan is at only 24% private expenditures, Manitoba at 25.3%, and Alberta 27.1%).

In dollars, private payment for health care is 5.3% higher in Ontario than Canada as a whole ($1,883 in compared with $1,787).

Total public sector expenditure for Ontario in 2013 is forecasted at only 67.7% of total health care expenditure, significantly below the Canada-wide average of 70.1%. Public sector expenditures in Ontario would need to increase 6.3% just to meet the Canadian average (and the Canadian average is significantly below the OECD average).

Photo: Canada-USA by Eric Fisher

Comments

More spending on new hospitals and new beds? Nope

Hospital funding: There is something off about the provincial government's Budget claims on hospital capital funding (funding to build and renovate hospital beds and facilities). For what it is worth (which is not that much, given the long time frame the government cites), the province claims it will increase hospital capital spending over the next 10 years from $11 billion to $20 billion – or on average to about $2 billion per year. But, this is just a notional increase from the previous announcement of future hospital capital spending. Moreover, even if we did take this as a serious promise and not just a wisp of smoke, the government's own reports shows they have actually funded hospital infrastructure about $3 billion a year over the 2011/12-2015/16 period. So this “increase” is really a decrease from past actual spending. Even last year's (2016-17) hospital capital funding increase was reported in this Budget at $2.3 billion - i.e. about 15% more th

Ford government fails to respond to 72% increase in COVID inpatient days, deepening the capacity crisis

COVID infections continue to drive up hospital costs and inpatient hospitalizations in Ontario. For the most recent fiscal year (April 1, 2022- March 31, 2023) hospital stays related to COVID cost $1.221 billion, according to new CIHI data. This is about 4% of total hospital spending, creating a very significant new cost pressure beyond the usual pressures of population growth, aging, inflation, and rising utilization. Costs for COVID related hospitalizations increased 22.2% in Ontario in 2022/23 from the previous fiscal year, rising from $999 million to $1.221 billion. That rise is particularly notable as the OMICRON spike of late 2021 and early 2022 had passed by the the 2022/23 fiscal year. The $222 million increase in COVID hospitalization costs came in the same year as the Ford government cut special COVID funding and, in fact, cut total hospital funding by $156 million. In total, there were 60,653 COVID hospitalizations in Ontario in 2022/3, up from 47,543 in 2021/2.

Paramedic Services in Canada: Structure, Privatization, Unionization and other issues

Governance and Funding : While police and fire services are usually municipal services, Emergency Medical Services (EMS) are typically controlled by provincial governments. In Ontario, regional municipal governments have responsibility for delivering and funding EMS. But even in Ontario the province plays a key role, strictly regulating EMS, providing funding for 50% of the approved land ambulance costs, and paying 100% of the approved costs for air ambulance, dispatch, base hospitals, First Nation EMS, and for territories without municipal government. Delivery : Like police and fire services, EMS is predominantly a publicly provided service in Canada. But businesses have now made some significant in-roads into EMS, primarily Medavie, a private corporation based in the Maritimes that describes itself as not-for-profit. Medavie goes back over 70 years, with its roots in health insurance. It still operates Medavie Blue Cross with 1,900 employees. It now a

Defend Public Healthcare

Search This Blog