Skip to main content

Hospital P3 scandal gets worse as Ontario Liberals and PCs say bring 'em on!

The public private partnership ("P3") hospital scandal in Montreal is getting even worse, if that is possible. 

As reported earlier, a police corruption investigation showed how SNC-Lavalin officials allegedly arranged payments of $22.5-million to McGill University Health Centre (MUHC) chief executive Arthur Porter and his side-kick Yanai Elbaz in exchange for ensuring SNC won the $1.3-billion contract. 

In total, eight people are facing charges and police describe this P3 as the "biggest construction fraud in the history of Canada".  Hospital CEO (and former Steven Harper Security Intelligence Review Committee chief) Arthur Porter is fighting Canada's attempts to bring him back home to face the charge: he had, rather conveniently, left the country.  

Now a senior SNC-Lavalin official has admitted that the company took design features from their competition when it became apparent their design was a flop. Someone within the McGill University Health Centre gave SNC a copy of the competition's architectural drawings, detailing a ward design favoured by  MUHC physicians. 

 Justice Charbonneau called SNC's actions illegal. 

Notably, SNC met directly with hospital officials in the middle of the bidding process: that is specifically forbidden to allow at least a degree of fairness in the competition.

SNC may wish to portray its scandals as from the past, but Charles Chebl, who was involved in the latest shenanigans was not disciplined – instead he got promoted and is now vice-president and head of construction at SNC. Charbonneau inquiry Commissioner Mr. Lachance noted that Mr. Chebl's career had not suffered. "After you have regularly cheated in such an important contract, instead of punishing you, they give you a promotion."

SNC-Lavalin is involved in Ontario P3s – indeed, just after the bribery scandal broke in December 2012, the Ontario McGuinty Liberal government awarded a consortia they are involved in an even bigger P3 contract -- the $2.1 billion P3 for the Ottawa LRT rapid transit project.

Despite all this, there is not the slightest sign that the Ontario Liberals will back off privatization of hospital clinical services or hospital P3s. As for the PCs, expect much worse: they see privatization as a miracle cure-all (up there with creating jobs by laying off 100,000 workers) .   

Notably, the Charbonneau Commission heard earlier that SNC deliberately went around Quebec's political party financing rules, leading to a flurry of donations to the governing Quebec Liberal Party in 2009. The donations came as the engineering firm was bidding on this very hospital P3 project

Photo: davehuehn, MUHC under construction


  1. Liberals and Conservative love triple-Ps, which is just privatization by stealth The wasted bliions of dollars in the e-Health and ORNGE scandals are a direct result of the Liberal's pro-privatization ideology.

  2. The NDP has also set up P3s when in office, e.g. in Ontario and Manitoba. Ontario's Highway 407, a gift to the private sector, was created by Ontario's NDP government in the 1990s. Manitoba's NDP government has set up several public-private partnerships.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Public sector employment in Ontario is far below the rest of Canada

The suggestion that Ontario has a deficit because its public sector is too large does not bear scrutiny. Consider the following. 

Public sector employment has fallen in the last three quarters in Ontario.  Since 2011, public sector employment has been pretty flat, with employment up less than 4 tenths of one percent in the first half of 2015 compared with the first half of 2011.

This contrasts with public sector employment outside of Ontario which has gone up pretty consistently and is now 4.7% higher than it was in the first half of 2011.

Private sector employment has also gone up consistently over that period. In Ontario, it has increased 4.3% since the first half of 2011, while in Canada as a whole it has increased 4.9%.

As a result, public sector employment in Ontario is now shrinking as a percentage of the private sector workforce.  In contrast, in the rest of Canada, it is increasing. Moreover, public sector employment is muchhigher in the rest of Canada than in Ontario.  Indeed as…

The long series of failures of private clinics in Ontario

For many years, OCHU/CUPE has been concerned the Ontario government would transfer public hospital surgeries, procedures and diagnostic tests to private clinics. CUPE began campaigning in earnest against this possibility in the spring of 2007 with a tour of the province by former British Health Secretary, Frank Dobson, who talked about the disastrous British experience with private surgical clinics.

The door opened years ago with the introduction of fee-for-service hospital funding (sometimes called Quality Based Funding). Then in the fall of 2013 the government announced regulatory changes to facilitate this privatization. The government announced Request for Proposals for the summer of 2014 to expand the role of "Independent Health Facilities" (IHFs). 

With mass campaigns to stop the private clinic expansion by the Ontario Health Coalition the process slowed.  

But it seems the provincial Liberal government continues to push the idea.  Following a recent second OCHU tour wi…

Hospital worker sick leave: too much or too little?

Ontario hospital workers are muchless absent due to illness or disability than hospital workers Canada-wide.  In 2014, Ontario hospital workers were absent 10.2 days due to illness or disability, 2.9 days less than the Canada wide average – i.e. 22% less.  In fact, Ontario hospital workers have had consistently fewer sick days for years.

This is also true if absences due to family or personal responsibilities are included.
Statistics Canada data for the last fifteen years for Canada and Ontario are reported in the chart below, showing Ontario hospital workers are consistently off work less.
Assuming, Ontario accounts for about 38% of the Canada-wide hospital workforce, these figures suggest that the days lost due to illness of injury in Canada excluding Ontario are about 13.6 days per year ([13.6 x 0.68] + [10.2 x 0.38] = 13.1).

In other words, hospital workers in the rest of Canada are absent from work due to illness or disability 1/3 more than Ontario hospital workers. 

In fact, Canad…