Skip to main content

Are employer paid drug plans sustainable?

A Great West Life Assurance executive recently claimed that private insurance for drug plans was becoming unsustainable -- unless changes are made.

Almost all private drug insurance plans are paid through employer paid  insured benefit plans (often bargained with trade unions).

In fact, although there were significant increases during the 90s and the first decade of this century, drug costs for insured benefit plans have leveled off.

For 2010, 2011, and 2012 private drug insurance costs have risen just less than 3.1% per year on average, according to the Canadian Institute for Health Information (Table A). This is a small fraction of the increases in the 1990s (where the average annual increase was 10.5%) or the first decade of this century (10.3% average annual increase).

Part of the slowdown in costs is that some high priced blockbuster patented drugs are coming to the end of their patent protection and are now facing competition from lower priced generic versions.

So, why is this the moment for an insurance industry executive to call for changes? Not, I hope, for more costs to be passed on to the public.

Notably, the public has seen much less relief than the insurance industry -- out of pocket costs for prescription drugs have increased at an annual average rate of 9.1% over 2010, 2011, and 2012 (12.6%, 8.5%, and 6.1%).  Given the wage increases employers are handing out these days, that is unsustainable.

Also notable: the public sector has seen the lowest cost increases, with an annual average increase of just 2.2% (2.2% in 2010, 2.6% in 2011, and 1.9% in 2012).  The public sector has been best placed to resist drug cost increases, it seems.

Moving costs to the public sector would be a significant blow to private health care: one-third of private health care spending is accounted for by drugs.  The only other item approaching private spending on drugs is private spending on all "other" health care professionals (dentists, chiropractors, physiotherapists, psychotherapists, etc.), at 32%.  Payments to hospitals account for 9% and payments to other institutions (e.g. LTC facilities) account for 10%.   These four categories account for 86% of private health care spending. (See line 48 on the "private" tab of this CIHI Excel table. Download for ease of viewing)

The increased costs in private sector drug spending have come despite a declining role in overall drug costs.

Since 1975 there has been a significant increase in the public portion of total drug costs.  In 1975, the private sector / public sector split was 85% private and 15% public.  Now the split is 62% -- 38%.  This move is appropriate as drugs have become a much more important part of health care and a much bigger part of the total health care spend.  So sharing the risk across the entire public makes more and more sense.

Photo: psyberartist


  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Ontario long-term care staffing falls far short of other provinces

CUPE and others are campaigning for a legislated minimum average of four worked hours of nursing and personal care per resident per day in long-term care (LTC) facilities.  New research indicates that not only is LTC underfunded in Ontario, it is also understaffed compared to the other provinces. 
LTC staffing falls short:  The latest data published by the Canadian Institute for Health Information (and based on a mandatory survey undertaken by Statistics Canada) indicates that staffing at long-term care (LTC) facilities falls far short of other provinces. 
Part of this is driven by a low level of provincial funding for LTC.

Ontario has 0.575 health care full-time equivalent employees (FTEs) per bed staffed and in operation.[1]  The rest of Canada reports 0.665 health care FTEs.[2] The rest of Canada has 15.7% more health care staff per bed staffed and in operation than Ontario.[3] 

No other province reports fewer LTC health care staff per resident (or per bed) than Ontario.[4]

Occupancy r…

More spending on new hospitals and new beds? Nope

Hospital funding:  There is something off about the provincial government's Budget claims on hospital capital funding (funding to build and renovate hospital beds and facilities).   

For what it is worth (which is not that much, given the long time frame the government cites), the province claims it will increase hospital capital spending over the next 10 years from $11 billion to $20 billion – or on average to about $2 billion per year.  But, this is just a notional increase from the previous announcement of future hospital capital spending. 

Moreover, even if we did take this as a serious promise and not just a wisp of smoke, the government's own reports shows they have actually funded hospital infrastructure about $3 billion a year over the 2011/12-2015/16 period.

So this “increase” is really a decrease from past actual spending. Even last year's (2016-17) hospital capital funding increase was reported in this Budget at $2.3 billion - i.e. about 15% more than they have ann…

Health care funding falls, again

Real provincial government health care funding per-person has fallen again this year in Ontario, the third year in a row.  Since 2009 real funding per-person has fallen 2.6% -- $63 per person. 

Across Canada real per person funding is in its fourth consecutive year of increase. Since 2009, real provincial funding across Canada is up $89 -- 3.6%.
In fact the funding gap between Ontario and Canada as a whole has gown consistently for years (as set out below in current dollars).

Ontario funds health care less than any other province -- indeed, the province that funds health care the second least (B.C.) provides $185 more per person per year, 4.7% more.  
Provincial health care spending in the rest of Canada (excluding Ontario) is now  $574 higher per person annually than in Ontario. 

 Ontario has not always provided lower than average health care funding increases-- but that has been the general pattern since 2005.
Private expenditures on health care have exceeded Ontario government increases …