Skip to main content

Public sector employment in Ontario is far below the rest of Canada

The suggestion that Ontario has a deficit because its public sector is too large does not bear scrutiny. Consider the following. 

Public sector employment has fallen in the last three quarters in Ontario.  Since 2011, public sector employment has been pretty flat, with employment up less than 4 tenths of one percent in the first half of 2015 compared with the first half of 2011.

2011-2015 public sector employment

This contrasts with public sector employment outside of Ontario which has gone up pretty consistently and is now 4.7% higher than it was in the first half of 2011.

Public sector employment 2011-2015


Private sector employment has also gone up consistently over that period. In Ontario, it has increased 4.3% since the first half of 2011, while in Canada as a whole it has increased 4.9%.


Private sector employment 2011-2015

Private sector employment in Canada 2011-2015


Public sector employment as percent 2011-2015

As a result, public sector employment in Ontario is now shrinking as a percentage of the private sector workforce.  In contrast, in the rest of Canada, it is increasing. Moreover, public sector employment is much higher in the rest of Canada than in Ontario.  Indeed as a percentage of private sector employment it is now almost 5 percentage points higher in the rest of Canada than it is in Ontario.  
Public sector employment Canada excluding Ontario 2011-2015 

Further, as a percentage of the population, public sector workers in Ontario fall well below the corresponding percentage for the rest of Canada.  


Public sector workers as percent of population 2010-2015

Indeed, private sector workers are a larger percentage of the population in Ontario than the rest of Canada.

Private sector workers as a % of population -- 2010 to 2015
If Ontario was like the rest of Canada, we would have 117,000 more public employees and 121,000 fewer private sector workers.  This despite having the capital of Canada in Ontario.

As noted last July, low revenue, not bloated public spending, drives the deficit in Ontario.  

Health care and social assistance workers: There has been a larger increase in “health care and social assistance employees” than for either public sector workers or private sector workers over the last five years according to Labour Force Survey data from Statistics Canada. 

In Ontario, the 11% increase from 2010 to 2015 is about twice the rate of increase of public sector and private sector workers (which increased 6.1% and 5.1% respectively over that period).  Given an aging population and increasing demand for health care utilization, rapid increases may well continue  -- but whether this drives up private sector health care workers or public sector health care workers is another matter. More on this in an upcoming post.


Health care employees 2010-2015


Notably, Ontario has both a lower level of health care and social assistance workers than the rest of Canada (relative to population), and the rate of increase in the number of health care and social assistance workers has been almost 1/3 faster in the rest of Canada than in Ontario.




Health care employees chart -- Ontario -- 2010-2015


More detail on the nature of the changes to the health care workforce will come in a future post.  


Data Sources: Statistics Canada CANSIM 282-0089 and CANSIM 282-0088

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ford Plans to Cut Health Care Worker Benefits by $250 million

Attack on health care worker benefits: The Ontario Ford government has specifically targeted in the Budget health care worker compensation  through cuts in premium payments (e.g. shift payments), overtime, and sick leave. "Improving" scheduling is also part of the plan.  The stated goalis to cut $250 million annually through such changes by 2021-22.

This is squarely aimed at hourly paid employees. Managers don't get overtime and premium payments, and they are not likely to be targeted by attendance management programs or scheduling "improvements". 

With about half a million hourly paid employees working in health care a $250 million cut would mean about a cut of about $500 per employee per year.  

The Ford government claims in the Budget that this will have "no impact on patient care or front-line staff."

In fact, a $500 cut may be low -- as it will be especially hard to harvest such amounts from contracted, for-profit corporations (e.g. in home care).  T…

Ford government promise falls far short of solving hospital hallway medicine problem

Tens of thousands of new Long-Term Care (LTC) beds needed just to offset aging
The new Progressive Conservative government in Ontario has promised 30,000 new long-term care beds over the next ten years, often connecting this to their promise to end hospital hallway medicine.  But how does this promise stack up with growing demand for these facilities?
Most people 85 and older live in collective dwellings (LTC facilities, seniors residences, multiple level of care facilities).  The setting with the largest number of elders 85 and older is LTC facilities, with about 35% of the population 85 to 89  years old and almost 40% of the population 90 to 94 years. Older people are even more likely to be in a LTC facility.
The population 85 and older is the main driver of the need for long-term care beds.
An additional thirty thousand LTC beds by 2028 will only partially offset the rapid growth in the 85+ population.  The ministry of finance projects 42.5% growth in the most relevant population (85 a…

Are health care administrative expenses out of control in Ontario?

The Progressive Conservative government has justified its health restructuring plans with the claim that administrative expenses are much higher in Ontario than in Canada. 
When introducing the reforms, health minister Christine Elliott claimed, “Over the last five years, Ontario has spent 30% more than the Canadian average in administrative expenses on its health care system.”  
Elliott did not indicate her source of information. Presumably, however, the Progressive Conservatives are referring to the CIHI simplified and user friendly “Your Health System” graphs. Those graphs show “administrative expenses” in Ontario at 5.8% in Ontario while it is 4.5% in Canada.  
This CIHI measure is actually fairly narrowly defined. It is the percentage of “the legal entity’s” total expenses associated with the administrative, finance, human resources and communications functional centres.
However “the legal entity” used for this estimate is [1] only for certain types of health care providers, and [2] …